Type your own firm name into Google and look above the first result. If a rival sits there, you have just met competitive keyword advertising. In May 2025 the New Jersey Supreme Court ruled on whether a lawyer may buy a rival firm name this way. It said yes, with one condition. Other states say no. So keyword advertising now sits among the few marketing tactics that one state permits and the next forbids.
What the Tactic Actually Does
Buying a keyword does not put your name inside anyone else’s listing. It buys a chance to show up in the sponsored slot when someone searches that word.
So a search for a rival firm can return your ad above their own website. The searcher sees a small label reading Ad or Sponsored. Yet people notice those labels to very different degrees, as the New Jersey record found.
Courts call this proximity marketing. A shop opens next to a busy one and catches the overflow. The fight is about whether a profession with advertising rules may do the same thing.
Nothing here is new to Google. Every retailer in the country does it. What changes in law is that the bar rules sit on top of the ad rules.
The States Split Three Ways
North Carolina got there first and said no. Its 2010 Formal Ethics Opinion 14 went through in April 2012. It holds that picking another lawyer’s name as a keyword breaks Rule 8.4(c). That rule covers dishonesty and deceit.
Texas went the other way. Opinion 661 landed in July 2016. It found that simply using a rival lawyer’s name as a keyword does not break the Texas rules. The ad itself must still say nothing false or misleading.

South Carolina agreed with Texas in Ethics Advisory Opinion 20-01. Maryland lined up with North Carolina in Ethics Docket 2022-02. Maryland put it bluntly. The point of the purchase, it said, is to take another firm’s earned name for your own gain.
- Permitted outright: Texas and South Carolina, under the usual advertising rules.
- Banned as dishonest: North Carolina and Maryland, under their versions of Rule 8.4(c).
- Allowed with a condition: New Jersey, which added a disclaimer duty in 2025.
- Silent so far: most other states, where no opinion exists either way.
So the first question is not whether the tactic works. It is which of those four groups you practice in.
What New Jersey Added
The New Jersey ruling is the most useful paper in the pile. The court did not decide on theory alone. It sent the question out for fact finding first.
A special adjudicator took expert evidence on how search auctions really work. He then reported that the current rules already handled any claim of deceit.
The holding splits the question neatly. Buying the keyword is placement, not a message, so it does not by itself break the advertising rules. The court then added a duty. A clear and conspicuous disclaimer must appear on the landing page reached from such an ad.
That disclaimer does real work. Someone who clicked expecting one firm learns at once that they reached another. The confusion the bar groups feared goes away, and the tactic survives.
Whether Keyword Advertising Pays
Set the ethics aside for a moment. The business case is weaker than most vendors suggest. Someone searching a specific firm name has usually chosen that firm already.
Those clicks convert poorly. Legal keywords also sit among the priciest in all of search. So you pay top rates for traffic that mostly bounces.
There is a social cost too. Local bars are small. Referral ties matter more than most marketing channels. The lawyer whose name you bid on will notice sooner or later, and someone will mention it.
Run the math before you run the campaign. Take the cost per click, the clicks you expect, and your real conversion rate on brand terms. Many firms find the whole exercise buys two calls a month.
When Someone Bids on You
The more common spot is the defensive one. You run no such ads, yet two rivals sit above your own listing when clients search for you.
Start by checking whether your state has ruled at all. Where the practice is banned, a short letter citing the opinion usually ends it. No firm wants that letter in a file.
Where it is allowed, you have two choices. Outbid them, or give the searcher a better answer. The second one is cheaper and lasts longer.
- Search your firm name monthly, in a private window, from your own town.
- Save a dated screenshot of whatever sits above you.
- Check your state bar for an opinion on competitive keyword advertising.
- Bid on your own name, which usually costs very little.
- Make sure your listing answers the question a name search implies.
The Cheapest Defense You Have
Bidding on your own name costs little. Your relevance score for your own brand is near perfect, so your cost per click stays low. Few rivals will outbid you for long.
Still, the stronger defense sits below the ads. A client searching your name wants your phone number, your address, your people, and proof that you handle their problem.
Give them all of that in the first screen. Firms that lose clients here usually lose them to a slow or vague home page. The rival above merely offered a faster answer.
One Line Worth Borrowing
Even where the tactic is legal, the New Jersey disclaimer is a smart habit. Because it costs nothing, and it removes the only fair complaint anyone can make.
So if you do bid on a rival name, say plainly at the top of the landing page who you are and who you are not. However blunt that feels, it is cheaper than an ethics inquiry.
Instead of guessing, write the line once and keep it on file. Then any future campaign starts compliant rather than hoping nobody notices.
What To Do This Month
Run the search. Take the screenshot. Read your own state rules. That is an hour of work, and it settles the question for your jurisdiction rather than somebody else’s.
Then ask a friend outside the firm to search your name and tell you what they see. Their answer is usually more honest than yours, because they have no idea what the page meant to say.
After that, look at what a client actually meets after the click. See how we approach search engine marketing and SEO for professional firms, or start with a free website analysis.


